Andrew Sullivan Says, “Enough!” To Extremists

Andrew-SullivanAndrew Sullivan, a British conservative (Tory), has written a devastating response to the extremism he sees in the modern Republican party. Again, he is no leftist. He flies is conservative flag proudly. But enough is enough. There is really no chopping down this piece. It’s an excellent rebuttal to ideological extremism, so I post it here in it’s entirety:

Between the humiliating and chaotic collapse of Speaker Boehner’s already ludicrously extreme Plan B and Wayne La Pierre’s deranged proposal to put government agents in schools with guns, the Republican slide into total epistemic closure and political marginalization has now become a free-fall. This party, not to mince words, is unfit for government. There is no conservative party in the West – except for minor anti-immigrant neo-fascist ones in Europe – anywhere close to this level of far right extremism. And now the damage these fanatics can do is not just to their own country – was the debt ceiling debacle of 2011 not enough for them? – but to the entire world.

Those of us who have warned for years about this disturbing trend toward ever more extreme measures – backing torture, pre-emptive un-budgeted wars, out-of-control spending followed, like a frantic mood swing, by anti-spending absolutism of the most insane variety in a steep recession, vicious hostility to illegal immigrants, contempt for gay couples, hostility even to contraception, let alone a middle ground on abortion … well, you know it all by now.

But the current constitutional and economic vandalism removes any shred of doubt that this party and its lucrative media bubble is in any way conservative. They aren’t. They’re ideological zealots, indifferent to the consequences of their actions, contemptuous of the very to-and-fro essential for the American system to work, gerry-mandering to thwart the popular will, filibustering in a way that all but wrecks the core mechanics of American democracy, and now willing to acquiesce to the biggest tax increase imaginable because they cannot even accept Obama’s compromise from his clear campaign promise to raise rates for those earning over $250,000 to $400,000 a year.

And this is not the exception. It is the rule. On abortion, the party proposes that it be made illegal in every state by amending the Constitution. Torture? More, please. Iran? It should be attacked if it merely develops the technological skill to make a nuclear bomb, let alone actually make one. Israel? Leading Republicans don’t just support new settlements on the West Bank. They show up for the opening ceremonies!

Gun control? A massacre of children leads to a proposal for more guns in elementary schools and no concession on assault weapons. Immigration? Romney represented the party base – favoring a brutal regime of persecution of illegal immigrants until they are forced to “self-deport” – or rounding as many up as they can. Climate change? It’s a hoax – and we should respond by shrieking “Drill, Baby, Drill!” Gay marriage? The federal constitution should be amended to bar any legal recognition of any gay relationships, including civil partnerships. Their legislative agenda in this Congress? To “make Obama a one-term president.” Not saving the economy, not pursuing new policies, not cooperating to make Democratic legislation better. Just destroying a president of the opposite party. And, of course, failing.

Then there is the rhetoric. In just the last fortnight, House Republicans have asserted that secretary of state Clinton faked her recent fall and concussion at home in order to get out of testifying on the Benghazi consulate attack. And then the Weekly Standardquotes a Senate Republican staffer saying: “Send us Hagel and we will make sure every American knows he is an anti-Semite.”

Enough. This faction and its unhinged fanaticism has no place in any advanced democracy. They must be broken. But the current irony is that no one has managed to expose their extremism more clearly than their own Speaker. His career is over. As is the current Republican party. We need a new governing coalition in the House – Democrats and those few sane Republicans willing to put country before ideology. But even that may be impossible.

We need a conservative party. Badly. An intellectually honest left and right are necessary to a functioning government. As a nation, we deserve better than this.

This entry was posted in Fiscal Cliff, Gun Control, Politics and tagged , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

9 Responses to Andrew Sullivan Says, “Enough!” To Extremists

  1. “We need a conservative party. Badly. An intellectually honest left and right are necessary to a functioning government. As a nation, we deserve better than this.”

    Okay I agree. But how do we obtain one?

    • Well, you’ve got me there. It’s certainly easier said than done. Voting certainly helps. Moderates and progressive conservatives have fled the GOP. That doesn’t help. If all the normal people abandon a party the crazies take over by default.

      All I can do personally is argue my case in a forum like this and vote in primaries. When enough crazies get defeated and normal conservatives like Jon Huntsman and Chris Christie win elections I think the more rational (and cynical) Republicans will soften up. Its all about winning elections.

      The nuts will always be there; they’re in the Democratic party as well, but have been moved to the fringes. There’s no reason the GOP can’t do the same.

      Of course, this could all be just wishful thinking on my part. Who knows how this will play out.

      • I agree with your analysis, but I can’t help thinking that there’s more that I can do than blog about what’s going on. Kinda feels like I’m sitting on my hands in a way.

      • Well you do a good job on your site, so its not like its in vain. Those of us who want a better Republican party have a tough slog ahead. We get attacked from the left and right. Its certainly easier to bunker down on the far side of ideology so you only have to argue with one side.

        One person can only do so much, but by persuading people, one at a time, and treating people with respect and dignity, you can nudge the debate a little bit.

  2. john zande says:

    Reasonableness and logic doesn’t seem to be the Teapublicans strength.

  3. Brian says:

    VERY well said. He nailed them on most every point. Now, let’s see if the American people pull their heads out and start to notice the damage being done. It’s nothing short of embarrassing that the popular vote was a close as it was in the presidential election. To think that nearly half of the country thinks that extremism is a viable option is a bit horrifying to say the least…

    • Its shocking when you realize how far out there the GOP is when compared to other countries conservatives.

      Its not healthy when the left and right in entirely in one party, and all the crazies are in another.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s